#0501
Fair Harbor
July
August

Charming Fire Island Cottage | 3BR/1BA | 4 Houses from the Bay

This is the kind of place that feels like Fire Island used to feel. A cozy three bedroom, one bath cottage that has been loved for years and still carries that classic beach town character you don’t find in the newer rentals.
The house sleeps up to six and comes fully loaded with the things that actually matter: brand new mattresses in every room, new A/C mini splits throughout so everyone stays cool, and a new dishwasher so you’re not hand washing dishes after a long beach day. The bones are old Fire Island, the comfort is brand new.

Bedroom layout:

Main bedroom: Full bed with A/C
Bedroom 2: Two twins with A/C
Bedroom 3: Two twins with A/C

Out back you’ve got a solid deck with a grill, which is really where the summer happens anyway. And at just four houses from the bay, you’re close enough to hear the water and close enough to walk everywhere.
At $3,000 per week, this is genuinely one of the better values you’ll find on the island right now.

Ask about June and September!

Sorry, no pets.